• Latest
  • Trending
Banning face masks: One step towards restoring law and order

Banning face masks: One step towards restoring law and order

October 6, 2019
Infrared images reveal hidden tattoos on Egyptian mummies

Infrared images reveal hidden tattoos on Egyptian mummies

December 3, 2019
Egypt’s non-oil private sector shrinks to slowest in over two years

Egypt’s non-oil private sector shrinks to slowest in over two years

December 3, 2019
Egypt’s Government Escalates Attacks on Journalists

Egypt’s Government Escalates Attacks on Journalists

December 3, 2019
Egyptian parliament delegation visits South Sudan

Egyptian parliament delegation visits South Sudan

December 2, 2019
Egypt prosecution orders investigation into leaking of student’s suicide video at Cairo Tower

Egypt prosecution orders investigation into leaking of student’s suicide video at Cairo Tower

December 2, 2019
Egypt launches new website for Passports and Emigration Administration

Egypt launches new website for Passports and Emigration Administration

December 2, 2019
New Technology Universities to Boost Egypt’s Vocational Education

New Technology Universities to Boost Egypt’s Vocational Education

December 2, 2019
iscovery channel to produce promo films on Grand Egyptian Museum

iscovery channel to produce promo films on Grand Egyptian Museum

December 2, 2019
Western correspondents get to choose when they face danger. Journalists in Egypt deal with it every day

Western correspondents get to choose when they face danger. Journalists in Egypt deal with it every day

December 2, 2019
Iraq unrest: PM Abdul Mahdi to resign after bloodiest day in protests

Iraq unrest: PM Abdul Mahdi to resign after bloodiest day in protests

November 30, 2019
Egypt’s VRapeutic is using virtual reality to tackle learning difficulties

Egypt’s VRapeutic is using virtual reality to tackle learning difficulties

November 30, 2019
Egypt’s Monorail assembly project begins June: Bombardier Transportation

Egypt’s Monorail assembly project begins June: Bombardier Transportation

November 30, 2019
Cairo Herald
No Result
View All Result
  • Egypt
    • Sinai
  • North Africa
    • Algeria
    • Libya
    • Morocco
    • Tunisia
  • World
    • Africa
    • Asia
      • China
      • North Korea
    • Canada
    • Europe
    • Latin America
    • Middle East
    • Russian Federation
    • United Kingdom
    • United States
  • National Security
    • Cyber Security
    • Defense
    • Immigration
    • Military
    • Terrorism
      • Islamic State
    • Politics
      • Democracy
      • Free Speech
  • Business
    • Economy
    • Free Market
    • Science
  • Culture
    • Art
    • Books & Literature
    • Education
    • Family
    • Food & Drink
    • Health
    • History
    • Movies & TV
    • Music
    • Privacy
    • Religion
    • Technology
    • Travel
    • Women & Children
  • Environment
    • Agriculture
    • Climate Change
    • Forests
    • Water & Oceans
    • Wildlife & Endangered Species
  • Sports
    • Auto Racing
    • Cycling
    • Golf
    • Olympics
    • Football
    • Tennis
    • Water Sports
Saturday, December 7, 2019
  • Egypt
    • Sinai
  • North Africa
    • Algeria
    • Libya
    • Morocco
    • Tunisia
  • World
    • Africa
    • Asia
      • China
      • North Korea
    • Canada
    • Europe
    • Latin America
    • Middle East
    • Russian Federation
    • United Kingdom
    • United States
  • National Security
    • Cyber Security
    • Defense
    • Immigration
    • Military
    • Terrorism
      • Islamic State
    • Politics
      • Democracy
      • Free Speech
  • Business
    • Economy
    • Free Market
    • Science
  • Culture
    • Art
    • Books & Literature
    • Education
    • Family
    • Food & Drink
    • Health
    • History
    • Movies & TV
    • Music
    • Privacy
    • Religion
    • Technology
    • Travel
    • Women & Children
  • Environment
    • Agriculture
    • Climate Change
    • Forests
    • Water & Oceans
    • Wildlife & Endangered Species
  • Sports
    • Auto Racing
    • Cycling
    • Golf
    • Olympics
    • Football
    • Tennis
    • Water Sports
No Result
View All Result
Cairo Herald
No Result
View All Result

Banning face masks: One step towards restoring law and order

October 6, 2019
in Asia, Featured, Law, National Security, News, Politics, World
0
Home World Asia
Post Views: 12

 

The Chief Executive’s announcement on Friday, that the government plans a ban on facial coverings by those who participate in public meetings and processions, as well as on those involved in unlawful and unauthorized assembles and riots, is a move in the right direction.

Like the bank robbers and rapists who don balaclava helmets, the men and women of violence, who have become an integral part of every public protest, rely on anonymity to protect themselves from the consequences of their crimes. This prohibition may at least give some of them pause for thought, although probably not the hard core. The violence and wanton destruction of recent times have been designed to undermine the rule of law, and anything that might deter those responsible from further depredations is to be welcomed. Quite clearly, people who have to display their faces in public are less likely to commit serious offences.

Similar measures, moreover, have already been adopted around the world, including North America and Europe, and have proved effective. In the US, for example, New York State adopted a face mask ban for participants in public protests as early as 1845, in order to promote public safety, with many other states following suit. In 2013, Canada also proscribed the wearing of face masks by those involved in riots and unlawful assemblies, although it also went one step further, and introduced an associated offence of wearing a mask with intent to commit an indictable offence.

RelatedPosts

Weapons of mass control, tactics of mass resistance

Chemicals missing from laboratories of universities

Radicals arrested after protesters and police stand-off at Polytechnic University

Black Bloc in Hong Kong is totalitarian

Protesters have seriously challenged their unique status

The Emergency Regulations Ordinance (Cap 241), under which the prohibition has, as a regulation, been effected, was enacted in 1922. It is a well-established tool for dealing with grave public order situations. The Basic Law, moreover, stipulates that pre-1997 ordinances “shall be maintained”, unless they “contravene this Law”, which the ERO clearly does not.

Although some people have claimed that the Chief Executive in Council does not have the power under the Basic Law to declare a state of emergency, Lam was at pains at her press conference to explain that she was not in fact doing this. What the ERO empowers the Chief Executive in Council  to do is to put in place an emergency regulation where this is in the public interest, because of a particular public danger, and this is exactly what has happened. On September 29 and October 1, masked thugs indulged in wanton violence, threw petrol bombs, attacked police officers, vandalised MTR stations and other public property, and the situation is ongoing. As an additional means, therefore, of addressing an existential public danger, the Regulation is legally justified.

Any suggestions, moreover, that that the Regulation infringes the basic rights of assembly and protest are irresponsible, and based on ignorance. The fundamental rights and freedoms contained in the Basic Law and the Hong Kong Bill of Rights Ordinance (Cap 383) are in no way affected by the prohibition, whatever the Civic Party’s alarmists might claim. Any human rights impact of the prohibition will have been carefully assessed by the Department of Justice’s highly experienced Legal Policy Division, which will have been keenly aware that the rights of, for example, freedom of expression, peaceful assembly and privacy, are by no means absolute, and may be subject to restrictions which satisfy the proportionality test.

As the Secretary for Justice indicated last week, the Hong Kong Court of Final Appeal, in two landmark judgments (FACV 8/2010, FACV 21/2015), has decided that, whenever government decisions are challenged on the basis that they contravene particular rights, a four-fold proportionality test should be applied by the courts. The impugned decision must, firstly, have a legitimate aim. Then, secondly, it must be rationally connected to that aim. Any restriction, thirdly, must be no more than is strictly necessary to achieve that aim. Then, finally, the court must examine the overall impact of the impugned measure, and decide if a fair balance has been struck between the general (public) interest and the individual rights intruded upon.  Applying these criteria to the Regulation, and given the need to protect society from thugs who conceal their identities when committing the gravest types of crime in order to avoid detection, there can clearly be no doubt that it is constitutionally defensible.

Of course, under the Basic Law, it is the function of the Legislative Council to scrutinize legislation, and it cannot simply be by-passed. This is precisely why the Regulation, as subsidiary legislation made by invoking existing legislation (the ERO), will be tabled for scrutiny at the Legislative Council at the first meeting of its new session, on October 16. If the Council so wishes, it can then, by resolution, and by virtue of the Interpretation and General Clauses Ordinance (Cap 1), amend the Regulation. This includes the power to “repeal, add to or vary” the subsidiary legislation. Although any such “negative vetting” does not have a retrospective effect, it must be exercised within 49 days of the tabling.

While it will not be possible to prosecute every offender under the Regulation, particularly when the numbers are large, there is certainly no safety in numbers. In 1992, in its judgment in the Soo Fat Ho case, the Court of Appeal decided that it is not open to a defendant to resist prosecution on the basis that other suspects have not also been charged with the same offence. Anyone who deliberately breaks the prohibition law is, therefore, liable to prosecution, even if there are logistical problems in holding each and every offender to account. In other words, provided cases are brought in good faith, there is no basis for offenders to claim that, because not everyone has been charged, they have been “selectively prosecuted”, In practice, where there are many suspects, prosecutors will generally prioritize the ringleaders.

Of more concern, however, are the maximum penalties provided for the two offences. Whereas 12 months imprisonment and a fine of HK$25,000 is the highest sentence for a person wearing a facial covering, 6 months’ imprisonment and a fine of $10,000 is the maximum for someone who refuses to remove it when asked by a police officer. Such maxima may well be an insufficient deterrent for many of the thugs, and they may require review. By comparison, the maximum sentence in Canada for its parallel offence is 10 years’ imprisonment, and, if the current penalties are not effective, a substantial enhancement will be unavoidable.

Although some people have sought to sensationalize the prohibition, it is a recognized tool of law enforcement around the world. In reality, it is a mild response to a grave situation, and no big deal. If, however, it does not do the trick, far tougher measures will be unavoidable.

Source :

China Daily

Tags: Banning face masksChief ExecutiveHong KongLaw

Related Posts

Infrared images reveal hidden tattoos on Egyptian mummies
Archaeology

Infrared images reveal hidden tattoos on Egyptian mummies

December 3, 2019
Egypt’s non-oil private sector shrinks to slowest in over two years
Business

Egypt’s non-oil private sector shrinks to slowest in over two years

December 3, 2019
Egypt’s Government Escalates Attacks on Journalists
Cairo

Egypt’s Government Escalates Attacks on Journalists

December 3, 2019
Egyptian parliament delegation visits South Sudan
Country

Egyptian parliament delegation visits South Sudan

December 2, 2019
Egypt prosecution orders investigation into leaking of student’s suicide video at Cairo Tower
Cairo

Egypt prosecution orders investigation into leaking of student’s suicide video at Cairo Tower

December 2, 2019
Next Post
Hong Kong protests: Teen fighting for life after ban on masks sparks night of violence

Hong Kong protests: Teen fighting for life after ban on masks sparks night of violence

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Translate

Popular Post

Infrared images reveal hidden tattoos on Egyptian mummies
Archaeology

Infrared images reveal hidden tattoos on Egyptian mummies

December 3, 2019
0

  Modern technology is illuminating tattoos on mummified, ancient Egyptians that until now had gone unnoticed. Infrared photography has helped...

Read more
Since Trump’s Mideast visit, extrajudicial killings have spiked in Egypt

Since Trump’s Mideast visit, extrajudicial killings have spiked in Egypt

August 31, 2017
Univ. of Michigan frat controversy — Make ancient Egypt great again!

Univ. of Michigan frat controversy — Make ancient Egypt great again!

August 31, 2017
Egypt’s plan to borrow $4bn in 2018

Egypt’s plan to borrow $4bn in 2018

August 31, 2017
How Israeli citizens are becoming stateless

How Israeli citizens are becoming stateless

September 1, 2017
  • About Us
  • Creative Commons
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Contact Us

Topics

Follow Us

About Us

Cairo Herald is part of Cairo Herald Media Group LLC, which delivers daily news around the globe.

© 2011 Cairo Herald

No Result
View All Result
  • Egypt
    • Sinai
  • North Africa
    • Algeria
    • Libya
    • Morocco
    • Tunisia
  • World
    • Africa
    • Asia
      • China
      • North Korea
    • Canada
    • Europe
    • Latin America
    • Middle East
    • Russian Federation
    • United Kingdom
    • United States
  • National Security
    • Cyber Security
    • Defense
    • Immigration
    • Military
    • Terrorism
      • Islamic State
    • Politics
      • Democracy
      • Free Speech
  • Business
    • Economy
    • Free Market
    • Science
  • Culture
    • Art
    • Books & Literature
    • Education
    • Family
    • Food & Drink
    • Health
    • History
    • Movies & TV
    • Music
    • Privacy
    • Religion
    • Technology
    • Travel
    • Women & Children
  • Environment
    • Agriculture
    • Climate Change
    • Forests
    • Water & Oceans
    • Wildlife & Endangered Species
  • Sports
    • Auto Racing
    • Cycling
    • Golf
    • Olympics
    • Football
    • Tennis
    • Water Sports

© 2011 Cairo Herald